Moderator: General Mods
potmunky wrote:I watched Serenity last night. SOOOOOO dissapointing.
I really wanted to like it, but I spose after the brilliant, (imo), Firefly, Whedon had a lot to live up to. (please bear in mind I aint seen the series for a while, so my memory is shat )
There were many reasons it failed the series;
Poss Spoilers ahead...
WTF did he have to kill-off two of the best characters!!!??? I loved the pilot, (his name escapes me at the mo), and the Shepherd. The Shepherd had a nice, mysterious quality about him that begged further investigation.
Why did he turn River into Buffy Mark 2!!!??? I realise she kinda was heading into this territory thru the series, but why use it for the film? I would have preffered to see a lot more of the Shepherd and his background, or perhaps Jayne.
Why rewrite so many character-traits!? I suspect a lot of the series' fanbase will be most-miffed at that. They just do/say/feel a lot of stuff that they never would have in Firefly!
Why reveal the Reavers/Rippers (God, my memory sux-like-an-electrolux )!?
Good SciFi/Horror Rule Number 1; "Never reveal the bad-guy til reet at the end, if at all, (especially if they dont look particularily nasty/scary!)"
Bloody-bollocking-Whedon;
You've gone and spoiled it now
Spoiler: |
-umm...killing the characters was necessary. and frankly, my dear, the fact that you give a damn shows me that he did it right. the problem with any serialized entity is that the "star" can't die. it gets downright ridiculous in comic books or the A-Team</i>. -river was always going to be buffy. did you not watch the final few eps of the series, or did you somehow manage to block them out. that was</i> the big unresolved story arc from the first season. jayne had his "history" ep. the preacher being no preacher was dropped in what? the final ep? it was tangential to the greater story. you can't condense an entire series/franchise into one movie. hey, I think they went a bit overboard on the buffy similarities myself. but puleeeze. it was going to happen. spud was sining that song since the movie was even mentioned. and I still maintain that the movie and series are more about the captain than his crew anyway. he sets out to save her. he has the crisis of conscience. -the whole "who are the reavers?" thing being explained was perfectly functional. it was never a horror story and the reavers were always - always</i> - humans throughout the series. the only thing new we get from the movie is their origin (how is the "truth" that we learn in the movie worse than "they flew to the edge of the galaxy and went mad?" - I mean, that's the perfect mythologizing of what actually happened. hell, I thought that was the best part of the movie. it was a seamlessly interwoven commentary about free will, the right to choose, individual vs. group, and blah blah blah...the same damn themes that are the staple of sci-fi from brave new world</i> to equilibrium</i> and their ilk |
spudthedestroyer wrote:urrrghh is that the dreadful one that was on scifi channel and they cancelled like there was no tomorrow?
Damn that series sucked, it was almost as bad as "veritas: the wank"
Not a fan
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 7 guests