that's probably because you are regarded as a leech until you build up your credits file (leave it running). Emule clients will be filtering you out as a leech, which is why a lot of files appear to have no sources when you jump over to ed2k.
There's absolutely no contest when you configure emule correctly (there's a lot of options, and you need a credits file on your side... no leeching allowed
). KAD sweetens the deal
The reason why I'm not overly bothered that edonkey2000 is banned is that Emule has a hardcoded 1:3 ratio these days, whereas edonkey2000 does not enforce a ratio after setting your upload at 10kb/s. Its pretty clear why emule clients ban edonkey2000, or at least treat it with lower status
btw. if your emule is "slower", you want to check if your running in Restricted mode; this is where you've downloaded beyond the ratio and its re-enforcing 1:3. Look in the bottom right of the status bar at the bottom of emule.
So, my criticisms are generally:
a) its abandonware and unsupported (and before this happened the devs were doing some very, very questionable things to the protocol)
b) its banned by emule clients for being abusive (to its own network
) so you don't see anywhere near as many completes
c) the speed is largely a placebo; the exception is that it does not enforce a ratio correctly and you can essentially leech past 10kb/s upload. So if your not uploading much, that would explain why you see edonkey2000 as faster
If you uploaded 1:3 or better, you should be seeing a significant boost in your download speed in emule.
If i start up with a blank credit file, it takes about 1-2 weeks to build one up... obviously the longer your on emule, the better your credits, the better your speed (or rather, the better your queue boost, peer speed isn't really affected)